BIKE TICKETS IN NEW YORK
Note: New York Bike Lawyers, Flanzig and Flanzig, LLP
does not focus on representing cyclists who are ticketed. We are a
New York Bike Crash firm. However, if you determine that you would like to consult with a traffic
lawyer, we would be happy to recommend an attorney with whom we have a
close working relationship to undertake your bike summons case
If you ride in New York or in the boroughs of NYC, you are aware of the
NYPD's push to write more cycle tickets. Cyclists are obligated to
follow the same rules of the road as motorists. Within the confines of
the City of New York, the New York State vehicle and traffic law allows
the City of New York, as well as other municipalities, to substitute certain
portions of the VTL for the Administrative Code of the City of New York,
and the Traffic Rules and Regulations of the City of New York.
The most common bike summons given are:
- Riding on the Sidewalk
- Failure to have proper lights or reflectors
- Failure to use and/or ride within available bike lanes
- Failing to obey a traffic control device (red light tickets)
A recent article by
Transportation Nation outlines the push on bike tickets in NYC. An excellent
updated report by Transportation Nation
writer Alex Goldmark discusses the shift in bike tickets this fall and
the new focus of the N.Y.P.D.
When given a ticket, most people are understandably angry and are in shock
that they actually received a "
bike ticket". The next feeling that pops into their head is "I am going
to fight it". Depending upon the ticket and the penalty, this may
make sense. You can fight alone, or you can hire a lawyer to fight it
for you. The reality is, in the City of New York, your chances are slim.
Unlike other jurisdictions, there is no plea bargaining with a prosecutor
in a traffic violations bureau. There's just you, the officer, and
the administrative law judge. Also, given the recent "ticket fixing"
scandal in the N.Y.P.D., officers are being watched and come prepared
for trial. There are now actual monitors in the court rooms watching the
police. If the case is dismissed, the officers now have to answer to their
supervisors as to what went wrong. Your hope that you will tell your sob
story is never going to happen because there is no one to hear it. You
will have the right to confront the officer, and offer evidence and testify,
but this is only after you plead not guilty and proceed to trial. The
trial will be short, and the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will make
his or her finding.
Is it worthwhile to hire a lawyer to fight a bike summons?
The answer to this question depends upon a number of circumstances, including
the type of ticket issued. Is the summons a violation of the Vehicle and
Traffic Law or E.C.B.? Is it a misdemeanor or violation of the Administrative
Code? Do you have an A.C.O.D. or other adjudication that requires you
to remain out of the Court system? Have you filed an application for immigration
to the U.S? What stage is the process in? What is the cost and penalty
of the ticket vs. the cost of the lawyer? All of these are factors to
consider when deciding to retain an attorney to fight the ticket, and
should be considered before you decide to hire a lawyer. A lawyer will
not be cheap, and also does not guarantee a dismissal. It does, however,
give you the advantage of having someone who has done this before, is
familiar with the process and burdens of proof, and is there to fight
on your behalf.
Does a Bike Ticket in New York mean points on your license?
Answer: No. Under Sec 131.3 of the NYCRR, bike and pedestrian violations
are not subject to the N.Y. State Point System
131.3 Point values (a) All traffic violations shall be assigned a point
value of two points, except as otherwise prescribed in subdivision (b)
of this section.
(7) The following violations shall not be assigned any point value:
(iv) Any parking violation
Any pedestrian or bicycle violation
Riding on a sidewalk in New York City
The relevant text of the statute:
§ 19-176 Bicycle operation on sidewalks prohibited.
a. For purposes of this section:
(1) The term “bicycle” shall mean a two or three wheeled device,
upon which a person or persons may ride, propelled by human power through
a belt, a chain or gears, with such wheels in a tandem or tricycle, except
that it shall not include such a device having solid tires, and intended
for use only on a sidewalk by a child.
(2) The term “sidewalk” shall mean that portion of the street,
whether paved or unpaved, between the curb lines or the lateral lines
of a roadway and the adjacent property lines, intended for the use of
pedestrians. Where it is not clear which section is intended for the use
of pedestrians, the sidewalk will be deemed to be that portion of the
street between the building line and the curb.
(3) The term “child” shall mean a person less than fourteen
years of age.
b. No person shall ride a bicycle upon any sidewalk, unless permitted by
an official sign. A person who violates this subdivision may be issued
a notice of violation, and shall be liable for a civil penalty of not
more than one hundred dollars, which may be recovered in a proceeding
before the environmental control board.
c. A person who violates subdivision b of this section in a manner that
endangers any other person or property shall be guilty of a misdemeanor,
punishable by a fine of not more than one hundred dollars, or imprisonment
for not more than twenty days or both such fine and imprisonment. Such
person shall also be liable for a civil penalty of not less than one hundred
dollars nor more than three hundred dollars, except where a hearing officer
has determined that where there was physical contact between the rider
and another person, an additional civil penalty of not less than one hundred
dollars nor more than two hundred dollars may be imposed. Such civil penalties
may be recovered in a proceeding before the environmental control board.
Enforcement agents shall indicate on the summons or notice of violation
issued pursuant to this subdivision whether physical contact was made
between the rider and another person. Any person who violates any provision
of this subdivision more than once within any six month period shall be
subject to the imposition of civil penalties, in an amount that is double
what would otherwise have been imposed for the commission of a first violation.
It shall be an affirmative defense that physical contact between a rider
and another person was in no way the fault of the rider.
d. Where a summons or notice of violation is issued for a violation of
subdivision c of this section, the bicycle may be seized and impounded.
Presently, New York bike lawyers does not focus on representing cyclists
who are ticketed. We are a New York Bike Crash firm. However, if you determine
that you would like to consult with a traffic lawyer, we would be happy
to recommend an attorney with whom we have a close working relationship
to undertake your bike summons case.